The HR guru's amongst my readers would agree that Talent Identification and Assessment are two critical pillars of Talent management . Simply put Talent Management facilities a process and culture which ensures that the best and brightest automatically bubble to the top . If we were to believe that an organization is a microcosm of a larger society then what we are witnessing today in most Indian organizations is also indeed true for Bollywood .
Many years ago
Anu Kapoor ran a show called "
Meri Awaaz Suno" - to me it was a Talent Management intervention .A little girl from
Bhilai won the hearts and imagination of India. That little girl was
Sunidhi Chauhan , the program was a process and a platform which allowed a top talent like her to get pan India exposure . Programs such as
Meri Awaaz Suno heralded the
beginning of Talent Management revolution in playback
singing @ Bollywood . Along the
journey were many such shows , and the latest one is the
Sangeet Ka Vishwa Yudh . We are now in the final stages of the program with
Amanat ,
Raja and
Aneek . These three singing sensations have come a long way displacing people like
Poonam Yadav,
Sumdeha and my heartthrob
Mouli. While all the singers were
undoubtedly brilliant , but without a process like the
Vishwa Yudh , these people would not have got an opportunity or an exposure that they well deserve . To put this in context , in
the good old days at Bollywood incumbency was a big factor ,
Lata Mangeshkar remained the playback Queen for decades without any
noticeable threat to her position . Was there a talent shortage in the country...???? , were there no
Mouli's,
Poonam's or
Sumedha's during her time ....I
don't think so , what was probably lacking was platforms like the ones that we are discussing . The power of these platforms are immense and the outcomes that they can create for an industry is what we are
experiencing first hand now.
I would like to highlight two key learning's from Bollywood which could be of use to HR professionals who engage in the process of Talent Management .
Let the Soul of the Process Flourish
What happens in the name of Talent Management are generally elaborate paper exercises and assessments which kill the soul of the process . By killing the soul of the process I am hinting at the complex psychometric tools often used to identify talent (however valid the consultants who peddle them claim to be ) are fraught with errors and to put undue emphasis on the tools only is disastrous .
Use Professional Talent Spotters and Talent Managers
Spotting Talent is not necessarily a function of competency frameworks or psycometry . The Aussie Cricket Board has talent scouts who scan the country and select young players with promise. A similar process happens thought he regional and city rounds of these Bollywood programs . In India however I have not heard of Talent Scouts in organizations . An individuals potential is often assessed in the context of his current and future roles . While I do not have a conceptual quarrel with this process , however happens that the potential assessment is left a bit too late for any meaningful development to happen , which leads to a situation wherein either the top talent is frustrated and leaves the organization or even worse stays back and becomes a cynic. While timing of assessment is important , the other critical issues is that potential assessment happens in the context of a set of Role Based Competencies and rarely on well grounded Generic Competencies . The challenge is of course to maintain a balance between the competencies required to deliver the current role and or future roles as also the ability to manage organizations and add stakeholder value . Often the second objective take a backseat
To conclude , I
believe that Indian organizations and HR processes should be capable of identifying the
Poonam Yadav's ,
Sunidhi Chauhan's ,
Shreya Ghosal's and
Mouli's of the world so that there is some real competition to
incumbements like
Lata or
Asha . "
Lata tai ,
Asha tai no disrespect meant ...you
probably had it a bit easy , but
Sunidhi will face far more competition as the Talent Processes of
Bollywood and getting stronger and stronger ..."