Showing posts with label Performance and Talent. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Performance and Talent. Show all posts

Saturday, September 29, 2007

Talent Management -Bollywood Style


The HR guru's amongst my readers would agree that Talent Identification and Assessment are two critical pillars of Talent management . Simply put Talent Management facilities a process and culture which ensures that the best and brightest automatically bubble to the top . If we were to believe that an organization is a microcosm of a larger society then what we are witnessing today in most Indian organizations is also indeed true for Bollywood .

Many years ago Anu Kapoor ran a show called "Meri Awaaz Suno" - to me it was a Talent Management intervention .A little girl from Bhilai won the hearts and imagination of India. That little girl was Sunidhi Chauhan , the program was a process and a platform which allowed a top talent like her to get pan India exposure . Programs such as Meri Awaaz Suno heralded the beginning of Talent Management revolution in playback singing @ Bollywood . Along the journey were many such shows , and the latest one is the Sangeet Ka Vishwa Yudh . We are now in the final stages of the program with Amanat , Raja and Aneek . These three singing sensations have come a long way displacing people like Poonam Yadav, Sumdeha and my heartthrob Mouli. While all the singers were undoubtedly brilliant , but without a process like the Vishwa Yudh , these people would not have got an opportunity or an exposure that they well deserve . To put this in context , in the good old days at Bollywood incumbency was a big factor , Lata Mangeshkar remained the playback Queen for decades without any noticeable threat to her position . Was there a talent shortage in the country...???? , were there no Mouli's, Poonam's or Sumedha's during her time ....I don't think so , what was probably lacking was platforms like the ones that we are discussing . The power of these platforms are immense and the outcomes that they can create for an industry is what we are experiencing first hand now.

I would like to highlight two key learning's from Bollywood which could be of use to HR professionals who engage in the process of Talent Management .

Let the Soul of the Process Flourish

What happens in the name of Talent Management are generally elaborate paper exercises and assessments which kill the soul of the process . By killing the soul of the process I am hinting at the complex psychometric tools often used to identify talent (however valid the consultants who peddle them claim to be ) are fraught with errors and to put undue emphasis on the tools only is disastrous .

Use Professional Talent Spotters and Talent Managers

Spotting Talent is not necessarily a function of competency frameworks or psycometry . The Aussie Cricket Board has talent scouts who scan the country and select young players with promise. A similar process happens thought he regional and city rounds of these Bollywood programs . In India however I have not heard of Talent Scouts in organizations . An individuals potential is often assessed in the context of his current and future roles . While I do not have a conceptual quarrel with this process , however happens that the potential assessment is left a bit too late for any meaningful development to happen , which leads to a situation wherein either the top talent is frustrated and leaves the organization or even worse stays back and becomes a cynic. While timing of assessment is important , the other critical issues is that potential assessment happens in the context of a set of Role Based Competencies and rarely on well grounded Generic Competencies . The challenge is of course to maintain a balance between the competencies required to deliver the current role and or future roles as also the ability to manage organizations and add stakeholder value . Often the second objective take a backseat

To conclude , I believe that Indian organizations and HR processes should be capable of identifying the Poonam Yadav's , Sunidhi Chauhan's , Shreya Ghosal's and Mouli's of the world so that there is some real competition to incumbements like Lata or Asha . "Lata tai , Asha tai no disrespect meant ...you probably had it a bit easy , but Sunidhi will face far more competition as the Talent Processes of Bollywood and getting stronger and stronger ..."






Monday, September 10, 2007

Coaching ......Child's play ...Isnt it

Well the latest buzz word in the Indian HR scene is Executive Coaching . As far as Indian managers are concerned executive coaching is not a new concept . I have heard of managers who have had coaches at least five years ago . However , the concept of coaching as a business proposition is gaining rapid currency amongst us in the last year or so. I know of friends and colleagues who are already or aspire to be Executive Coaches . There are some who call themselves Performance coaches and some who just coach ...(performance or otherwise) . When I first heard of real coaches , I was much younger and I dismissed them as personal shrinks to some CEO or wannabe CEO...., but the trend is rapidly changing , almost everybody either wants to be a coach or be coached , which has created this demand for "Your Friendly Neighbourhood Coach" and their USP is ...I don't need to know anything about your business ,or your pressures , I can just coach ....fantastic isn't it . I witnessed a similar phenomena in the US in 2001 . I was looking for a Training Manager , and I had shortlisted some 40 people for a face to face discussion . At least 7 of them (who had no training experience before) told me , that " Of course I can train...., whats the big deal...." . Drawing parallels from the training example , of course any human being can coach anybody else , bring to bear life's perspectives and add value....does it not sound simple enough.

I am sure Marshal Goldsmith (the God of Executive Coaching ) would dismiss me as a cynic and a non believer of people process ...but my disconnect is for the following reasons :

a) To be able to coach others , the coach should not be insecure .....unfortunately most of the coaches that I know are really insecure ( my data is based on a minuscule set of the world of coaches and hence I am aware that I make a sweeping generalization here , but my world view is limited to my experiences ...sorry about that ) and for all the good reasons want to prove to their coachee how smart they are .....and their notion of adding value is to leave you with a feeling that I am actually better than you

b) Coaching as a service will be potent only when the coach is truly interested in the development of the coachee . The kind of money that a good coach commands in the US market ( I am told that a certain Indian CEO Coach charges USD 20K ) for a day' s session makes me feel that it is a very very good business , so to be honest , I also want to be a coach and start making that kind of money ,who cares if I am really interested in the development of my coachee. I can fake it , and if I am Indian , I can add some spiritual masala to a Westerner and help him in his self discovery...cool isn't it ....I like this guy Dr Deepak Chopra , heard him once ....man he was a good speaker ....did he add value ....certainly not !!!

c) I am fundamentally against this notion that a coach can be a person who has no clue of the context of the coachee . Most of my coach pals tell me that you have to be able to ask the right questions ...this paradigm beats the hell out of me ....how do I even ask reasonable questions (forget right ones) if I dont know business and its intricacies . Well a lot of our Indian coaches are probably not the best business managers who graduate into this profession for motives best known to them

I was talking to a friend about enabling people a couple of hrs before I penned down this post . And in my discussion with this person , I told her that the ability to enable people comes only when one is deeply connected at all levels with the individual and has mastered an unknown equation wherein he can reach the individual at the cognitive and affective level . By this notion , I cannot be and should not be a coach, I cannot engage with all and sundry at a level which is required to unlock people's potential . As I sign off , with deep regret , let me confess that I am very simple human being and can't be a Coach

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Talent Trap-The Cost of Development ?


Yesterday after work, I had logged into my system and had a G Talk conversation with a former colleague of mine (Mr J), who is a very senior manager in the manufacturing sector. He quit his job a couple of years ago and took up an international assignment. In the next paragraph, I am replaying the conversation without getting into the exchange of pleasantries and trivia which approximately took approximately five minutes
……
Mr J:……….. you know my nephew ….the young chap you met when you came to my home ……has decided not to pursue higher education

I was quite surprised , I had spend a couple of hours with this kid (J’s nephew…) and the entire conversation was about his studies and how he wants to set himself up for success by pursuing a good degree and thereafter an MBA from a top tier school …….


Me: What happened to him? …he was supposed to do a MBA …….why did he quit….

Mr J: God only knows, he has joined a KPO and is getting paid well…he tells me that’s where the future lies and not in traditional education …….. his peers from college have joined the same place …this company came to campus and …….that’s that

Me: You mean bright kids now opt for a career in KPO’s and then don’t want to pursue higher education …

After the conversation I called up some HR Managers and recruiters in the KPO business, and to my surprise they confirmed that they have started picking up smart college graduates to work for them as Junior Analysts , according to these people it made good sense to get the number crunching done by lower cost resources and hence this shift in the recruitment pattern . It sounded very logical to me, however I quizzed them on career management plans for these young people. As I would have expected , HR was too busy in hiring and on boarding them and had no time to think about career management….This was exactly the genesis of this post ….the unintended consequences of development.

As a country we are in the midst of a transformation ,shedding our image as a backward, centrally controlled economy to a nation with one of the best talent pools with a very favorable demographic profile (Nearly 60 per cent of our population between the ages 15-59, and more than half below the age of 25. In contrast, countries including the US, Europe, Japan and China have a more aged population with dependency ratios likely to increase over the same period) ……but are we slowly and surely getting caught into what I call a “talent trap”…..

The Talent Trap

The Talent Trap is a situation wherein the best of our college grads get attracted to KPO jobs and do not pursue higher education…which creates a fundamental void in the pipeline for managerial jobs. What could possibly happen in the next ten years, the attractiveness of the KPO industry as an employer would reduce (higher automation, process improvements, would gradually take away the knowledge component of these jobs and make it boring –like a BPO job) and therefore these bright kids of today (in absence of proper career planning by their employers …which I suspect is what is going to happen) will land themselves in a situation where their employability would reduce. As a consequence the nation would have lost a lot of bright young minds, and the young people would not have any meaningful careers to look forward to.

To put the talent trap phenomenan in context, I had posed this question to a global executive whom I met after three years in Mumbai this Sunday (11 March 2007). He recognized the issue and his response was that this happens in developed countries, there are lots of examples in the US where people choose not to go to Wharton or a Harvard and pursue a stress free career all their lives. I agree that this happens in the US, but the contexts are different:

a) India’s currency to development is its talent, and the right kind of talent doing the right kind of job. Which this essentially means is that the best of our brains should pursue higher education and contribute differentially than others in the process?,while I support the HR initiatives that NASSCOM is taking to improve the quality of the workforce for the classical BPO operations (NASSCOM Assessment of Competence (NAC),Certification Program for Frontline Management etc ..), these KPO hiring have a large impact on the competitiveness of the nation .

b) The context of US and India are a bit different. As a developed nation US can probably afford to have a percentage of its brightest college grads take up “easy” jobs, which is a choice that an informed individual is making in that county. However as far as India is concerned ,I am not too sure if the young kids are making an informed choice , they are attracted by the money , the fancy name that they work for , and the team parties that are thrown occasionally , for them it’s a good happening place to be…who cares for education anyways ….. are we converting the best talent into mediocre people by this process…!!!

c) It makes eminent sense for the businesses to hire such people (cost advantages …) in the short run, but it sucks away the cream of talent thereby depleting the managerial pipeline of the nation. I also recognize the fact that these venture funded KPO’s need to manage costs and show performance on a quarter on quarter basis , but in the long run it's going to land itself in a situation where it would have a workforce which is demotivated and expensive ( considering the hikes that are given in the sector..) hence the question that I would like to pose here is “does it really make business sense , in the long term to hire such resources ,though there are obvious gains in the short run…”

So where does all of this leave us , assuming that hiring bright minds for KPO jobs is a reality and the immediacy of financial pressures will make it difficult for the employers to recognize the long term ramifications of this hiring ….. the only solution lies in a structured process of Talent Development (not a fancy word , it's different from simply training ) , so that the careers and the abilities of these young people are not eroded over time ….what do you think ? , do write in …..

Monday, February 19, 2007

Performance Ethics in Indian Companies

McKinsey and Company (http://www.mckinsey.com/) has a proprietary Performance Ethic framework with which it establishes the differentiating characteristics of hi-performance organizations. I have been following the study with keen interest and inspired by Mckinsey , last year (2006) launched a study of my own called “Performance Ethic Survey” of Indian companies. I worked on the premise that there are two key levers of a hi-performance culture which are:

Performance Differentiation – The existence of processes which can identify superior performers consistently and reward them differentially. Here rewards includes both cash and non –cash rewards
Managing Underperformance – Ability to deal with underperformers either by weeding underperformers or developing underperformers.

The scope of my study was to understand how Indian organizations were managing underperformance and also differentiating performance. This study covered a healthy mix of real economy and services companies ( 17 in all , of which 8 were from services ) and the key findings from the survey data were as follows,


a) Distinct and evident shift towards differentiation either in application of bell curve or forced ranking. This is a trend across sectors
b) Old Economy companies generally have a lower percentage of their workforce as their top performers
c) Old economy , conservative companies are also moving from undifferentiated remuneration to higher levels of differentiation
d) Most companies do have Performance Improvement Plans ( PIP’s) , some PIP processes are mature , but as a trend most companies ensure that separation occurs if the PIP process fails (typical timelines are 6-12 months)
e) Large conglomerates like Tata’s and others recognize that superior performance needs to be rewarded differentially ,some companies within the conglomerates are already doing sharp differentiation ,while others are evolving in the space. Older entities like Tata Steel, VSNL, Indian Hotels, Tata Motors are also making a philosophical shift in this direction.


When I started designing my survey, I was expecting that real economy companies are still tentative about the issues of performance differentiation, but I was pleasantly surprised when the HR Heads of these companies repeatedly told me that for their companies to survive in this competitive world it was imperative for them to establish processes of accountability to the last man. They felt that Performance Management was a key tool to make things work for them, so there has indeed been a lot of emphasis on performance management processes in the last few years.

Traditionally, Performance Management has always been equated with the Performance Appraisals, in the course of my survey discussions not one HR Head spoke about the process of performance appraisals; their responses were much more broad-based and issues of development, managing talent, aligning organization and individual goals were of great relevance to them.


What was more encouraging for me was that there was a higher level of recognition of the fact that people need to be rewarded and managed differently. This was evident across all the sectors that I studied, particularly in the financial services industry the process of differentiation was really stark.
From a social perspective, India is a very indirect society and Indians find it difficult to confront each other with data and facts, least we end up offending each other. This behavior is manifested in organizations through the process of performance management as well. Managers find it difficult to give meaningful feedback on face to face conversations with their direct reports, this is a phenomenon that I have grappled with for the last few years and any amount of appraiser training does not seem to help. As part of the survey I found out that this behavior of managers (inability to call a spade a spade) is also changing.


In conclusion these changes augur well for India’s competitiveness, but the journey has just begun and as HR professionals we need to be at it with missionary zeal! (Continue to improve Performance Management processes)

Friday, February 16, 2007

Talent, Meritocracy and National Competitiveness

  • As years pass by India continues to transform itself into the world’s back-office and a preferred destination for off shoring work of all kinds , but slowly and surely we are eroding our competitiveness by eroding a culture of meritocracy !!

    All of us will agree that our recent competitive positioning is based on our ability to produce and manage talent (talent here is used as a very broad concept ...), people who can follow routines efficiently and get work done at half the price than it can be done anywhere else (the cost and efficiency game) . The central premise of our model is that we are smart people, so we can learn, adapt and deliver faster, be it in the IT/ITES or any other form of off shoring.

    The quality of Talent is a function of the education system and the stronger our primary education system, the larger is the talent pool, and therefore greater is our ability to compete with others. As you would expect our political system is blissfully oblivious of the basics and preoccupied by the politics of education rather than viewing education as a basic lever of national competitiveness.

    In the name of empowerment, the HRD Ministry has successfully institutionalized the reservation in institutes for higher education. The rationale provided was that this step is an affirmative action and is aimed at enabling the backward section of society. Not taking sides on the relevance and importance of reservations in today’s context, what is evidently clear is that Mr Singh and his team are taking a short-cut by opening the gates of the temples of learning to people who could not necessarily get there on their own . While the reservations can be seen by some as an important social subsidy (and that’s why political parties like the CPI(M) seem to be backing the concept) , this intervention has far reaching consequences on the culture of meritocracy and some of these consequences are as follows :

    · Changes the basis of competition for entry to academic institutions, erodes the position that the IIT’s and IIM’s hold internationally.
    · Increases in the number of seats without a commensurate investment in the infrastructure of the institute reduces academic standards
    · Creates a fundamental disbelief on the notion of meritocracy – I am rewarded by a seat because of my birth and not because of who I am.

    Those of us who work in organizations surely know that the competitiveness of business is also greatly eroded if meritocracy is not rewarded, organizations which do not have a culture of meritocracy perish and those that do grow and prosper. This holds true for Nations as well

    Furthermore the Government has collected thousands of crores through the Education Cess route and I am told that they have not found any meaningful use for the same. One would believe that a nation like ours is resource starved and hence we cant do much to improve our education system, however contrary to this belief we have collected enough cash in the form of taxes and now we need to do something very rapidly. Unfortunately our education policy makers seem to have no will to do something about it …they are of course busy managing their political bosses and their agenda .

    I would grant our policy makers for public education with the intelligence although they mostly look senile to understand that the problem lies with the school system and the solution is not by giving reservations to the OBC’s , SC’s and ST’s , but what beats me is that the government does not have the will to work on issues which are important for the existence of the very nation.