Monday, June 25, 2007

30 years of Lal Salaam in Bengal

This month the CPI(M) lead Left Front Government finishes 3 decades of being in power in West Bengal , a feat which is perhaps unparalleled in the history of democracies across the world . The Left regime has undoubtedly had some very significant achievements which even a die hard critic of Communism like me would concede . The land redistribution ,agrarian reform are probably the greatest achievements in the last 30 years .However , here is what has not worked for them

a) Education

West Bengal would once take pride of its education infrastructure ...... the successive Left governments has ensured that education institutions are systemically destroyed all across the state . About a decade ago , I had the privilege of being a Visiting Faculty in the Universities of Burdwan and Midnapore and even in those times appointment to teaching position in colleges of these universities were based more on affiliation to the red flag than merit !!!

b) Erosion of meritocracy

The government has somewhat been able to sell the idea that the society/state owes its citizens a living , and hence has been able to create a class of babus who do not believe in hard work , they regale in their addas, pontificate about life , are found chatting in the street corner's of Kolkatta . These babus form the bulk walk of the CPI(M) cadre , a community which reflects the growing intellectual decadence of Bengal....The hard working and ambitious Bengali has long left Bengal and has found places like Bangalore , Mumbai or Delhi to be more hospitable to their ambitions

c) Industrial Unrest

Inspite and despite of Buddhadev's claims about industrialization , the last 3 decades has seen flight of all kinds of industries from Bengal. As a child , I have seen the thriving Hoogly belt which was host to companies like ICI , Dunlop's , Hind Motors, GKW , Metal Box etc ....all closed down or in marginal existence thanks to the belligerent CITU (the workers arm of the CPIM). I wish Buddha babu well in his efforts to get industry back to Bengal , but I think its an uphill task to undo the damage done by the Jyoti Basu's and Pramod Dasguptas of the world .

In conclusion

I can go on and on with this list ...but will leave it for some other day. All that I have written in this post is based on my personal experiences with the Left front from 1977 the year the front came to power (and we moved into Kolkata) till 1996 when I decided to leave the city ....probably never to come back again....at least till the "reds" are in power in my state . If God were to grant me one wish ...it would be "defeat the Left and lets have a progressive govt" ..Bengal needs it and Bengalis deserve it ...Amen

9 comments:

Shreyasi Deb said...

I guess this is the voice of all rational bengalees! Thank you for raising it...

DreamCatcher said...

Yes thank you for this post. But where is the viable alternative? (Momota?...naaah!) I don't see any in the near future. We all need to put our thoughts together on this. The primary reason for LF's survival has been the resounding failure of the opposition on several counts...days of pontification is over, we need solutions. A group of like minded, progressive and politically well versed people who can make a difference. See anyone in the horizon?

Unknown said...

Congrats on voicing our anguish which nowadays people turn to ignore ....Had the left Govt had the acumen then we wudnt be all out in diff cities making our dreams come true ....away from our folks our roots is a heavy price we all paid ....I hope the efforts of Buddhadeb Bhattacharya bring out some results for the new generation .....

Moushumi said...

Good one- couldnt agree more

Niladri said...

I so much wish the collective conscience of Bengalis push us to defeat the Left and restore some amount of sanity in Bengal

Anonymous said...

Well, well, well. Another Trinamul followetr trying to vent his feelings!

Why pick West Bengal only? Why not Mumbai, Manchester....

Get a life (and pick friends with good grammatical skills)

Niladri said...

Well Anonymous it would be great if you would have let ur name . Anyways , I u got me wrong , I am not really pro Trinamool , but certainly anti Left any with anybody who can kick the left out of Bengal . However I dont think ur serious when you try to compare Mumabi with West Bengal ....you must be kidding right . Buddy grow up the Left has caused irrepairable damage to our state...time to stand up and protest ...join in ...

Anonymous said...

I do not associate with life's failures.

I am unashamedly pro-left.

so there!

Niladri said...

Not associating with life's failures and ascribing to redundant political views are probably two diffrent things .Being pro-Left is not the issue at all , after all I am unshamedly pro-Right , however the myopia displayed by the Left Front over te last 30 years and the economic decay of Bengal are to be condemned at all levels . I have lived in Bengal and to a certain extent am well versed with the politics of the Left and may I assure you that my views are not mere opions , there is enough and more data to back the claims that I make

Cheers